| |
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN
DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
IRVING ROSNER, et al., on Behalf of Themselves
and
All Others Similarly Situated, Plaintiffs
v.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA , Defendant.
Case No. 01-1859-CIV-SEITZ
NOTICE OF PROPOSED SETTLEMENT OF CLASS ACTION
LAWSUIT
A proposed settlement has been reached in Rosner, et
al. v. United States of America, a class action lawsuit
on behalf of all persons who have claimed (or at any time
could claim) any interest in the personal property on the
Hungarian Gold Train (a train of approximately twenty-four
freight cars that contained personal property taken, seized,
confiscated or stolen by the Hungarian government from Hungarian
Jews) [“Hungarian Gold Train Settlement” or the
“Settlement”] i.e. Jewish Hungarian victims of
Nazi persecution and their heirs. This class action settlement
may affect your rights. If you wish to comment upon, object
to, or exclude yourself from the Hungarian Gold Train Settlement,
you must do so following the procedures described in this
Court-approved document. If you do nothing, you will be bound
by the final judgment in this case.
This is not a lawsuit against you. Your
participation in this lawsuit or acceptance of any benefit
from its settlement will not cost you anything.
LEGAL BACKGROUND
On April 8, 2005, the United States District Court for the
Southern District of Florida preliminarily approved the Hungarian
Gold Train Settlement. The Complaint alleges that the United
States mishandled the personal property contained on the Hungarian
Gold Train after the U.S. Army took such property into its
custody at the conclusion of World War II and that the United
States improperly disposed of the property. For more details
regarding these allegations, please visit the Hungarian Gold
Train Settlement web site, www.HungarianGoldTrain.org
, and review the First Amended Complaint and amendments thereto.
Please check the web site periodically for updates about the
Settlement. The United States denies any legal liability related
to the handling of personal property contained on the Hungarian
Gold Train.
SETTLEMENT TERMS
Under the terms of the Hungarian Gold Train Settlement:
1. The United States has agreed to pay up to USD $25.5 million
into a Settlement Fund.
2. The Settlement does not provide for direct payments
to Class Members as compensation for property lost on the
Gold Train. Instead, the money will fund social service programs
benefiting eligible Class Members according to the Plan of
Distribution, described in point 3 below. After years of litigation,
the parties concluded that attempting to provide compensation
payments directly to Class Members would be impractical because
of the difficulties of determining which individuals had property
on the Gold Train (or were heirs of such individuals), and
because the administrative costs of determining which Class
Members would be eligible for such compensation payments could
very well equal or exceed the total size of the Settlement
Fund. The difficulties of proof are compounded by the lack
of records documenting whose property was on the train and
where it eventually wound up.
3. Approximately USD $21 million will fund social service
programs benefiting Class Members, born before May 8, 1945
who lived in the 1944 borders of Hungary some time between
1939 and 1945, who are in need. Only such Class Members will
be eligible for social service benefits. Class members who
did not live within the 1944 borders of Hungary between 1939
and May 8, 1945 are not eligible to receive social service
benefits. The funds will be allocated pursuant to the terms
of the distribution plan filed with the Court, and be disbursed
over a period that could extend up to five years. "Need"
will be determined based upon criteria similar in nature to
those used in that place for existing programs benefiting
Nazi victims (e.g., individuals' health, disability and financial
situation). The services provided to individual Class Members
will be limited to the extent that funds are available. A
detailed proposed Plan of Distribution for such funds will
be developed by the Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against
Germany, in consultation with Class Counsel, Class Representatives
and others. This plan will be available for review and comment
by June 10, 2005 at www.HungarianGoldTrain.org
. The Plan of Distribution will be submitted to the Court
for its review and approval.
4. USD $500,000 of the Settlement will fund an archival
project to collect documents and artifacts relating to the
history of the Hungarian Gold Train and looting of the Hungarian
Jewish community during World War II. The archives will be
available for scholarly research and educational purposes,
Class Members' use, and for future generations. Three experts
will select a qualified research institution or museum to
compile and maintain the archives.
5. In addition to the up to USD $25.5 million, the United
States will pay for class notice, that is, the cost for notifying
Class Members of the Hungarian Gold Train Settlement.
6. At the end of the case, the United States Government
will issue a statement of acknowledgement about the events
regarding the Hungarian Gold Train. The United States Government
solely will determine the contents of the statement. The United
States also represents that, to the best of its knowledge,
all World War II-era documents relating to the Hungarian Gold
Train have been declassified. If any documents that have not
been declassified are brought to its attention, the United
States will review the document to determine whether classification
is warranted.
7. The Court will determine the appropriate amount of attorneys'
fees, expenses and costs to be awarded. Class Counsel will
apply for an award of attorneys' fees and costs in an amount
that will not exceed USD $3.85 million, plus incentive awards
of up to a total of USD $150,000, consisting of up to USD
$5,000 for each of the named plaintiffs for their efforts
in prosecuting this case. Class Counsel's application for
fees, expenses and costs will be available for review and
comment by June 17, 2005 at www.HungarianGoldTrain.org. Those
amounts, if approved by the Court, will be paid (and deducted)
from the $25.5 million paid by the United States.
YOUR RIGHTS
Right to be Excluded from the
Settlement (Opt Out)
If you want to exclude yourself from the Settlement, you
must write a letter that says:
For Hungarian Nazi Victims: I request
to be excluded from the settlement in Rosner, et al. v.
United States of America , Case No. 01-1859-CIV-SEITZ
(USDC Southern District of Florida). I affirm that I lived
in the 1944 borders of Hungary sometime between 1939 and 1945
and my family had property seized, confiscated or stolen by
the Hungarian government pursuant to Decree 1600 of 1944,
Decree 8306 of 1944, or other similar Hungarian law, policy
or practice that could have been on the Hungarian Gold Train.
For Heirs of Victims: I request to be
excluded from the settlement in Rosner, et al. v.
United States of America , Case No. 01-1859-CIV-SEITZ
(USDC Southern District of Florida). I affirm that I am a
legal heir of someone who lived in the 1944 borders of Hungary
sometime between 1939 and 1945 and who had property seized,
confiscated or stolen by the Hungarian government pursuant
to Decree 1600 of 1944, Decree 8306 of 1944, or other similar
Hungarian law, policy or practice that could have been on
the Hungarian Gold Train.
For both victims and heirs, you must include your full name,
address, and telephone number, and you must sign the letter
yourself. Mail the letter to:
Hungarian Gold Train Notice Provider
P.O. Box 1570
New York, New York 10159
Your letter excluding yourself
from the Settlement must be postmarked by August 1, 2005.
You cannot exclude yourself
by telephone or e-mail.
If you exclude yourself from the Settlement, you will not
be bound by the Settlement. You also will not be able to benefit
from the social service projects funded by the Settlement.
If you exclude yourself from the Settlement, you will not
be permitted to submit a written objection to the Settlement
and you will not be allowed to oppose or comment about the
Settlement at the Fairness Hearing, as described in "Right
to Comment or Object" below.
If you do nothing or do not exclude yourself
from the Settlement, you will be bound by the terms of the
Settlement, if it is approved by the Court, and you may be
able to benefit from the social service projects funded by
the Settlement. However, you would not be able to bring your
own lawsuit against the United States relating to the Hungarian
Gold Train.
If more than 100 Hungarian
Nazi victims, or more than 5,000 heirs of victims, request
to be excluded from the Settlement, the United States shall
have the right to terminate the Settlement Agreement. If more
than 100 Hungarian Nazi victims request exclusion and the
United States does not terminate the Agreement, the United
States shall have the right to reduce the Settlement Fund
by an amount equal to USD $400 per victim who requests exclusion,
and the reduction shall be allocated to the country in which
the victim seeking exclusion resides.
Right to Comment or Object
Any written comment or objection to the Settlement
must be postmarked by August 1, 2005. If your comment or objection
to the Settlement is not postmarked by August
1, 2005 , it may not be considered by the
Court. The Court will decide whether Class Members who do
submit timely objections will be permitted to speak at the
Fairness Hearing.
The Court has scheduled a Fairness Hearing, which you may
attend, on September 26, 2005 at 10:00 a.m.,
at the United States District Court for the Southern District
of Florida, 301 N. Miami Avenue, Miami, Florida 33128, to
consider whether to give final approval to the Settlement.
The scheduled date of the Fairness Hearing provides Class
Members with sufficient time to review and comment upon the
Settlement and Plan of Distribution for the up to USD $25.5
million.
If you do not exclude yourself from the Settlement, you
may submit a written comment or objection. You may be represented
by a lawyer of your choosing at your expense, but you need
not use a lawyer to comment or object. If you wish to speak
at the Fairness Hearing, your written submission should include
a request of the Judge to consider that. The Court will consider
timely submissions mailed to:
Hungarian Gold Train Notice Provider
P.O. Box 1570
New York, New York 10159
You cannot comment or object by telephone
or e-mail.
Release of Claims
If the Settlement receives final approval from the Court
and you do not exclude yourself, that is, opt out of the Settlement,
you will release all claims, known or unknown against the
United States that: (1) arise out of or are related in any
way to any or all of the acts, omissions, facts, transactions
or occurrences that were directly or indirectly alleged, asserted,
described, set forth or referred to in Rosner, et al.
v. United States of America; and (2) are, were or could
have arisen out of or been related in any way to the United
States’ possession and handling of the Hungarian Gold
Train property. The complete release is set forth in the Settlement
Agreement.
YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS AND CHOICES
If I want to: |
What that means: |
Must I write a letter? |
| Stay in the Settlement |
I would agree to allow funding for
social service programs for eligible victims from the
Settlement Fund. If I qualify, I would be potentially
eligible for social service benefits. I give up the
right to be part of any other lawsuit against the United
States about the Hungarian Gold Train. |
No |
| Object to the Settlement |
I would like to stay in the Settlement,
but tell the Court why I do not like the Settlement.
|
Yes, postmarked by August 1, 2005
|
| Speak at the Fairness Hearing
|
I would like to ask the Court for
the opportunity to speak at the Fairness Hearing on
September 26, 2005. |
Yes, postmarked by August 1, 2005
|
| Exclude Myself
|
I do not want to take part in the
Settlement or be bound by its terms. I will not be potentially
eligible to receive social service benefits. I remain
free to bring my own case against the U.S. Government.
[The United States Government has the right to terminate
the Settlement or reduce the amount paid to the Settlement
Fund if there is a significant number of Opt-Outs, see
"Right to be Excluded from the Settlement (Opt
Out)," last paragraph, for details.] |
Yes, postmarked by August 1, 2005
|
More Information Is Available
This notice is only a summary of the Settlement. To review
a complete copy of the Hungarian Gold Train Settlement, or
any other information about the Settlement or case, you can
contact Class Counsel—they are your lawyers—or
the Notice Provider:
Hungarian Gold Train Notice Provider
P.O. Box 1570
New York, New York 10159
E-mail: HGT@claimscon.org
Toll free Help Center number:
| Australia |
1-800-35-7208 |
| Canada |
1-800-562-0831 |
| Hungary |
00-800-737-47576 |
| Israel |
1-80-921-4806 |
| United States |
1-800-562-0831 |
From anywhere else in the world, if you are
unable to reach the Help Center number listed above, please
ask your operator to place an international reverse charge
(collect) call to the United States, to the following number:
646-519-8701. You will not have to pay for this call.
Class Counsel Appointed by the Court
| Steve
W. Berman, Esq.
R. Brent Walton, Esq.
Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro LLP
1301 Fifth Avenue, Suite 2900
Seattle , WA 98101
Tel: (206) 623-7292
Fax: (206) 623-0594
brent@hbsslaw.com
|
Jonathan
W. Cuneo, Esq.
Michael Waldman, Esq.
David Stanley, Esq.
Cuneo , Waldman & Gilbert, LLP
317 Massachusetts Ave. NE
Suite 300
Washington , DC 20002 |
Samuel
J. Dubbin, Esq.
Jeffrey Kravetz, Esq.
Dubbin & Kravetz, LLP
701 Brickell Avenue
16 th Floor
Miami , FL 33131 |
DO NOT WRITE OR CALL THE COURT OR THE CLERK’S
OFFICE FOR INFORMATION
|
|